Throwback Tuesday: The Easiest Way to Evaluate Reading Comprehension Skills
*Originally published March 6, 2014 when the boys were 9, 8(Alec), & 6.
My husband and I were putting the kids to bed last night and I was finding Alec's books all over the place.
I'd flag him down only to have him tell me, "oh, I read that one already."
Ordinarily I wouldn't think much of it but these were new books from the library. I quickly counted them up and asked "you read 8 books in the last two days?!"
Now, that in and of itself isn't that shocking when it comes to Alec but 6 of these were chapter books!
My husband was very skeptical (and I'll admit I couldn't help thinking-- "really??" in my head as well) and so my husband told me I needed to ask him about the stories to see if he was really reading them.
I'd flag him down only to have him tell me, "oh, I read that one already."
Ordinarily I wouldn't think much of it but these were new books from the library. I quickly counted them up and asked "you read 8 books in the last two days?!"
Now, that in and of itself isn't that shocking when it comes to Alec but 6 of these were chapter books!
My husband was very skeptical (and I'll admit I couldn't help thinking-- "really??" in my head as well) and so my husband told me I needed to ask him about the stories to see if he was really reading them.
I told my husband that if he didn't believe Alec he needed to ask him himself.
Then, of course, my husband realized he had never read any of these books and he asked me "how will I know what the story is about and if he's telling me all about it or not." "Just ask him and you'll know; if he really has read these books he will talk your ear off about them!"
Well ten or so minutes later my husband was begging Alec to stop telling him about his books and to start getting ready for bed.
I often have people ask how I know if my boys are really reading the book they have chosen if I never have them read aloud to me.
I have people ask how I know they understanding what they're reading if I never ask them any questions.
Here's how:
- I listen when they talk about their books!
That's pretty much it in a nutshell!
My boys are eager to share and tell others about good books that they're reading and when they retell they tend to use a lot of details. When they're talking my ear off; I know they're enjoying the book, understanding the story, and really reading.
I know when my boys are really reading a book because they look engrossed in the story, they don't want to put it down and I can see their eyes and lips moving as they track words across the page.
Once all the boys were tucked in my husband turned to me and said "what other 8 year old reads 8 books in two days! That's a lot of reading!"
I just shrugged.
Alec LOVES to read and these past few days I have been finding Alec in weird positions (feet on the couch and head on the floor; legs folded over his head like a pretzel, hiding under blankets, etc.) while reading book after book.
He's a fast reader and he loves reading.
As I sat at computer with all three kids in bed I could hear him reading out loud to all of his animals.
He reads fast, accurately and with such unbelievable expression. He was yelling, squealing, and I could just hear him dissolving into fits of laughter.
I knew there was no way he was skipping through these stories only reading the first few and last few chapters (like my husband suspected) because he genuinely loves the stories and can't wait to find out what will happen next.
If I could only get my other two boy to enjoy reading half as much as Alec I'd feel like the best homeschooling mom ever!
Amazing! Does he still love reading?
ReplyDeleteYep! He's always got a few extra books going "just for fun." Within his first few weeks of starting college he had already went to the public library near the school and got a library card so he could start requesting books.
DeleteThis is such great advice! As a kindergarten teacher, I remember having conversations with families about the importance of asking questions or asking children to tell you about their favorite part of a story or why something made them happy/sad or what might happen next. This was important when reading to a child, then with them and it was equally important as their independent skills grew. Fluency was great but comprehension was everything and so important in developing a love of reading!
ReplyDeleteAbsolutely; if they aren't understanding what is happening in the story they sure aren't going to enjoy or even love it.
DeleteI have often wondered especially with my son if he's reading his books properly but each time I've asked he's given me a detailed account. In fact I think my kids reading comprehension is better than mine, they both have great recall whereas I find myself re-reading a chapter over as I realise I haven't taken it in.
ReplyDeleteYes! They remember so many more details than I ever did! I still struggle to remember names even after finishing up a book I usually have to Google another summery of it just to remember what their names were so I can write up my own blog summary/recommendation.
DeleteIt sounds like Alec really enjoyed reading, I hope he still does. My girls used to read a lot and would talk my ear off about their books, now they don't read as much but if they do they still non-stop talk about what they are reading.
ReplyDeleteAlec is still a pretty voracious reader but my other two rarely read at all (I mean Evan still has to since I require it in our homeschool but I don't think Ian has read anything at all since graduating from college).
DeleteIt"s so wonderful to raise a good reader! I'm happy to say that both of my adult children are great readers and put me to shame. They both read over 100 books a year!
ReplyDeleteAw, that is wonderful! That's how I always was too and I tend to think Alec will be the same way.
DeleteMy eldest was like that - and she taught herself to read by herself at 3 - it was amazing. But mid high school she just sort of stopped reading for pleasure. I don't know if she's ever got back into it...but then I sort of stopped reading for pleasure in my 20s...got back into it in my 30s....
ReplyDeleteI hear a lot of people stop reading for pleasure in high school and college and some pick it back up in "adulthood" but others sadly never seem to. I definitely didn't read as much fun stuff when I was in college but my reading really picked up once I had my boys and spent far more time in the house than out to dinner/clubs/movies, etc.
DeleteThis is one of those "if you know, you know" kinds of things. I love that you could hear him reading to his animals, complete with voices and expression!
ReplyDeletehttps://marshainthemiddle.com/
You know, even just re-reading this post I could hear his little voice and squeals and giggles!
DeleteYou are so insightful. I was like that with reading while my cousin could care less about books.
ReplyDeleteI wonder if it's innate that some of us love it so much?
Xoxo
Jodie
I think it has to be; I've been asking around and it seems like people who love reading experience books differently than those that don't-- not that I've done any sort of formal study but it's definitely something I've been wondering about for awhile.
Delete